Case story

  • Panama

Parties

CAO Case - Panama / Pando Montelirio-01 / Chiriquí

Complaint Regarding Electron Investment S.A, Panama 2010

This case story originates from BASESwiki.org, a platform based on wiki style contributions from a virtual network or individuals, companies and organizations with relevant expertise. Though some of the information may be outdated or inaccurate due to the wiki-nature of the BASESwiki platform, they still present a valuable resource. ACCESS is reviewing and updating all BASESwiki case stories. 

Story

The Pando Montelirio project, recently approved by IFC, consists of two run-of-river hydroelectric power plants to be operated in cascade on the Chiriquí Viejo River in Western Panama. The plants, totaling 85 MW in installed capacity (Pando, 33 MW and Monte Lirio, 52 MW), are being developed by Electron Investment, S.A. a joint venture between Inveravante Inversiones Universales S.L. of Spain, and the Panamanian entity Grupo Eleta. The total project cost is estimated to be $291.7 million.

In January 2010, sixteen community and environmental organizations based in the Chiriqui province filed a complaint with the CAO. The complainants believe they will be adversely impacted by development of the project in their region due to a number of social and environmental concerns. These include lack of a participative consultation process with communities, lack of a cumulative impact assessment, possibility of flooding to communities downstream, endangering of fish and other species, over-exploitation of water resources and the river, limited community access to water, high levels of sedimentation that affect water quality, and negative impacts on the natural landscape and on mangroves.

CAO Action

In February 2010, the CAO determined that the complaint met its eligibility criteria. A CAO Ombudsman assessment was initiated and the team began work with the parties to explore options for resolution.

To better understand views and perspectives of all stakeholders on the ground, a CAO Ombudsman team traveled to Panama in June 2010 to meet with complainants, company, community members, and local and national authorities. In July, the team returned to the field to discuss the draft assessment report and next steps with stakeholders. Key stakeholders agreed to continue to work with CAO Ombudsman in addressing the issues raised through a facilitated dialogue process.

Outcome

CAO has completed its assessment and with the agreement of the parties concerned is facilitating a dialogue process for key stakeholders to help improve mutual understanding and address their concerns.

The Inter-American Development Bank (IADB) is also providing long term financing to the Pando-Monte Lirio project, and the complaint received by CAO was also submitted to their Independent Consultation and Investigation Mechanism (known by its Spanish acronym, MICI) by the same complainants. Therefore, CAO is coordinating closely with IADB staff and MICI.

References

CAO case story page: http://www.cao-ombudsman.org/cases/case_detail.aspx?id=156

Contributor(s): This article was modified by Nicolaclayre (4), Kyle (1), Ejfturnbull (1), and Maloneypark (1).